By the Modern Weddings editors
Updated November 15, 2026: new guide with 25 picks, every price checked.
The traditional 5 year anniversary gift is wood, and the best wood gifts are personal: your first-dance lyrics engraved in walnut, a map of the lake where you got engaged, a board you’ll pull out every Friday night. Our favorite is the engraved song lyrics panel from RevivalWoodworking, a 9-by-12 walnut, maple or cherry panel with your song cut into it, $112.56 on Etsy.
Our editors went through Etsy’s woodworkers and engravers for solid wood pieces in walnut, oak, cherry, maple and cedar. We favored shops with long review histories and U.S. workshops, read every listing for wood, size, personalization and shipping, and checked each price on November 15, 2026. Where a maker explains their work better than we could, we quote them.
Under $50 | $50 to $100 | $100 to $200 | $200 and up
5 year anniversary gifts under $50
For the one who dresses up for anniversary dinner
dfuss Personalized Walnut Cufflinks
Round walnut faces engraved with his initials, set in silver or gunmetal. They have 4.9 stars from more than 1,500 reviews and ship from Virginia.
For the couple who cooks together
CopperFoxCompany Personalized Cutting Board
An engraved board with a handle, in walnut, cherry, mahogany or bamboo, personalized with your names or wedding date. $19.99 gets the mini size; walnut starts at $29.99.
It’s the most-reviewed pick here, with 4.9 stars from more than 9,600 reviews.
For the one who saved every ticket stub
EngraveMyMemories Engraved Keepsake Box
A wooden memory box with your names engraved on the lid, in natural, gray or dark walnut finishes. Fill it with the save-the-date, the vow cards and the bar napkin from your first date before you wrap it.
It’s marked down from $74.95.
For a place to drop your rings at night
MuujeeWeddings Engraved Anniversary Tray
A walnut tray engraved with your names, your date and how many years you’ve been married. It comes in two sizes, $36.99 or $41.99.
Put it on the nightstand or by the door, wherever your rings and keys land.
For the couple whose first dance song is on vinyl
MonmouthWoodDesign Vinyl Record Flip Rack
An open wood rack that holds albums upright so you can flip through them, in oak or walnut finishes. Add engraving for $55.99.
It ships free from Nashville and has 4.9 stars from about 1,100 reviews.
For the couple who honeymooned in a national park
TimberandStain National Park Wood Sign
A layered wood sign styled after national park entrance signs, with your names, your wedding date and “The Adventure Continues.” Pick an animal for the design: moose, bear, wolf, buffalo, fish or sasquatch.
$45.50 is the 16-by-10-inch size, marked down from $70.
5 year anniversary gifts from $50 to $100
For your favorite wedding photo
KnoxWoodCreations Solid Walnut Picture Frame
A handmade frame with maple splines at the corners and acrylic glass. “I use large planks of reclaimed and upcycled walnut,” the maker says.
$50 is the 4-by-6 size; 7-by-9 is $70, and it goes up to 24 by 30. The shop is in Tennessee and has 5 stars from more than 800 reviews.
For the husband who checks the time on his phone
MuujeeWeddings Engraved Wood Watch and Walnut Box
A men’s watch with a wood case and wood band, in a walnut gift box. You can engrave the watch, the box or both, with different messages.
It has 4.9 stars from about 1,000 reviews, and you can add a band-resizing tool for $4.
For the reader
TealsPrairie Walnut and Brass Bookends
A pair of black walnut bookends with engraved brass plates. They ship from Houston and are marked down from $89.99.
For the one who empties his pockets on the kitchen counter
WoodProShopUS Personalized Valet Tray
A divided catchall for a wallet, watch, keys and wedding ring, engraved with his name or your date. It’s $76.49 in walnut, a little less in oak, maple or cherry.
It has 5 stars from more than 2,300 reviews.
For the couple who met in one city and married in another
A framed wood map with a heart cut over the spot that matters to you, made in Ohio. $89.10 is an 11-by-14 with one heart; two hearts start at $116.10.
For the family recipe in Grandma’s handwriting
MorningJoyCo Handwritten Recipe Cutting Board
The shop engraves a handwritten recipe, from a photo you send, onto a maple, cherry or walnut board. One engraved side starts at $89.60; the lower listed price is for a board with no engraving.
It has 5 stars from more than 1,200 reviews.
For the one who builds the cheese board at every party
NorthernRootsWI Live Edge Walnut Charcuterie Board
Black walnut with the natural edge left on, made by a woodworker in Wisconsin. $93.75 is the 16- to 18-inch board, marked down from $125; engraving and a care kit cost extra.
No two have the same edge, so yours will look a little different from the photo.
5 year anniversary gifts from $100 to $200
For the couple who still dances to their wedding song
RevivalWoodworking Engraved Song Lyrics
Your first-dance lyrics engraved into a 9-by-12-inch walnut, maple or cherry panel, in a print or handwritten font, with your names and date. The lyrics can be laid out in a heart.
This is our top pick because it’s personal in a way most wood gifts aren’t, and it looks good on a wall. The shop, in Lafayette, Louisiana, has 4.9 stars from more than 1,700 reviews.
It’s on sale through Dec. 5; the regular price is $150.08. A 12-by-16 costs more.
For the wine people
Timber2Art Reclaimed Wine Barrel Tray
A round serving tray made from reclaimed wine barrel oak. The maker says it’s “handcrafted from authentic oak wine barrel wood,” and the grain shows.
It ships from California and has 4.8 stars from 126 reviews.
For the one who works from home
AetherArtCrafts Solid Wood Desk Organizer
A minimalist document tray in solid cherry or walnut that ships from California. $145.79 is one layer in cherry; walnut is $164.09, and you can stack two or three layers.
It’s on sale through Dec. 1; the regular price is $239.
For the one whose jewelry lives in a dish by the sink
Keepsakede Solid Walnut Jewelry Box
Four drawers, a flip-up mirror and two side doors with hooks for a dozen necklaces, in solid walnut. It’s built to sit on a dresser or vanity.
It’s marked down from $195.99 and ships from California.
For the couple who still does date night outside
MikelCustoms Picnic Basket Table
A wooden picnic basket that opens into a small table, from a shop in Oregon. You can add one of the shop’s engraved designs, two wine-glass slots for $195 or a tablecloth for $187.
It has 4.9 stars from 126 reviews. Pack it for your anniversary dinner.
For the lake house, the hometown or the honeymoon
A layered wood map of any place in the world, with the water picked out in blue. The 11.5-by-10-inch, four-layer version is $182, on sale for $127.40 through Nov. 21.
It has 5 stars from more than 1,000 reviews. It ships from Ukraine, so order at least three weeks ahead.
5 year anniversary gifts $200 and up
For the one who brings you coffee in bed
WoodProShopUS Breakfast in Bed Table
A folding bed tray in walnut and maple, with engraving available. Use it for breakfast, a book or the TV on a Sunday morning. It’s marked down from $249.99.
For the wall that needs something
LavenderGrain Cedar Live Edge Wine Rack
A 4-foot solid cedar wine rack with the live edge left on, from a shop in Florida. It holds bottles on the wall like a piece of art. We saw it briefly marked down; the regular price is $295.
For the couple with a running chess rivalry
JoyfulOrdinaryThings Walnut Chess Set
A 16.5-inch walnut and beechwood board with built-in storage and resin pieces. $330 is the full set; pieces alone are $285.
It’s handmade in Vietnam and has 4.9 stars from 400 reviews.
For a jewelry box she’ll keep for 50 years
OnVardFurniture Walnut Jewelry Box
A small solid walnut box lined in felt, from a furniture shop in Ohio. $335 is the small size with a maple lid and base; all-walnut is $365, and large sizes run $431 to $452.
It has 4.9 stars from 200 reviews.
For the whiskey drinker’s right hand
GrownRings Jameson Whiskey Barrel Ring
A wood ring “crafted from authentic Jameson Irish Whiskey Barrel Oak,” with platinum veins following the grain and smoked, darkened edges. The shop says each ring is handmade by its maker, Tyler, and sealed against water.
It comes in widths from 4mm to 10mm, has 5 stars from 68 reviews and ships from Delaware.
For the couple who has run out of room for records
hifiwoodworks Solid Hardwood Record Player Stand
A record console with a shelf for the turntable on top and storage for 100 to 190 records, in solid oak, cherry, maple or walnut with a natural wax finish. It ships flat from Ohio and goes together with the included hardware.
$950 is the 20-inch width in oak, cherry or maple; walnut starts at $1,100.
How much should you spend on a 5 year anniversary gift?
Whatever you’d spend on a birthday, or a little more if you’ve been meaning to replace something worn out. If you’re also planning a dinner or a weekend away, keep the gift small and personal.
Wood comes from the traditional anniversary list that Emily Post popularized. The modern list says silverware for year five, so a set of flatware counts too, but wood is the one people expect.
Order early. Almost everything here is engraved or made to order, and some ships from overseas. Two to three weeks is safe for most picks; give the maps and the record stand longer.
Celebrating a different year? Our paper anniversary gifts cover year one, and our anniversary quotes for your wife help with the card.



























